The Supreme Court of Georgia recently vacated a child support order that had an unsupported deviation. Stowell v. Huguenard, S10A1700 (2011). In that case, the father filed a motion to modify his child support and alimony obligation after a substantial change in his employment. After a trial, the court reduced the father's child support obligation to $981.25 per month plus "an annual payment of 25% of any gross commissions or other irregular income received above his $3500 monthly base salary." Id. at 1. The father appealed, alleging that Georgia law did not support the additional 25%. The Supreme Court of Georgia agreed with the father.
In general, child support is computed using both parents' gross incomes to get the presumptive amount of child support, and then adding to or subtracting from this amount using deviations that serve the best interests of the child. OCGA ยง19-6-15. Click here for a more detailed analysis of how child support is computed.
In this case, there was no question that the father's child support obligation of $981.25 per month was correct given the parties' respective incomes. However, the child support worksheet"contains no reference to the trial court's requirement that [the father] pay 25% of any income over his base salary of $3500 every month" as required. Id. at 4. In addition, "the trial court declared on the worksheet that there were no deviations to the presumptive child support amounts." Id. at 5. The 25% was addressed as a provision in the modification order, but the order lacked "the written findings or special interrogatory findings that an amount of child support other than the amount calculated is reasonably necessary." Id. The Georgia Supreme Court held that "the trial court's requirement that [the father] pay 25% of any income above his monthly base salary of $3500 results in a deviation from the presumptive amount of child supportset forth by the child support guidelines" and, since this deviation was not support buy written findings or entered on the child support worksheet, the modification order must be vacated.Id. at 11-12.